The Hog Dynasty

2024 Offseason Schedule

February 29 - Last Day of 2023 League Season

March 1-8 - Transition Tag Bidding (If Needed)

April 25 - NFL Draft 1st Round Watch Party

May 24 - Rookie Draft Starts

July 4 - FA Auction Starts

August (after FA ends) - Weekly Waivers Open

September 1 - Regular Season Starts

Week 10 Lucky or Good Standings

Vlad has emerged as the top team by actual winning %, which lines up with his All-Play standing despite the fact that he's actually gotten some bad luck.  Out of the other contending teams, Mick and Blake have been the most unlucky.  Meanwhile, Scott, Emil, and Scott have benefitted the most from schedule luck.

Advanced note: 9 weeks in, each game is 11.1% of the season so far.  So Vlad's team, with a 11% gap effectively deserves and extra win compared to his actual performance.

Week 10 Primer

Raw Mark vs Blake is the headline matchup this week and it could have an impact on who gets a playoff bye week.  Ian has the easiest possible 3 game run coming up and is hoping to come out of it at the top of the divisions (and league?).

Smackdown Two great matchups jump out in this division.  Mick is hoping to get revenge for his week 5 loss and keep Emil from having complete shit-talking rights for a whole year (a win for Mick would give him a foot into the playoffs as well).  Meanwhile, Robby and Scott face off in the most impactful individual game of the season so far.  The winner will be clinging on to playoff hopes, while the loser could really be in dire straits (depending on Mick's result).

Week 9 Lucky or Good Standings

In this new view (idea courtesy of Mick) I'll highlight each team's All-Play winning % compared to their actual winning %.  For anyone who doesn't understand All-Play, it just gives you a record every week based on how you would do facing off vs every team, not just the team you actually faced.  So for example Mick would have recorded a 10-1 record in Week 8 since he had the second highest score of the week, but in reality he went 0-1 since he got unlucky and faced off against the top scorer.

The chart below is sorted from the highest to the lowest All-Play record.  It also highlights teams that have performed significantly better than their actual records with green bubbles, and teams that have been worse than their actual records with red bubbles.  Out of the contending teams, Mick and Vlad have been the most unlucky.  Meanwhile, Matt, Scott, Emil, and Ian have benefitted the most from schedule luck.

Advanced note: 8 weeks in, each game is 12.5% of the season so far.  So Vlad's team, with a13% gap effectively deserves and extra win compared to his actual performance.

Week 9 Primer

Raw The playoff contenders in the Raw division have tough matchups in the last week of cross-division play, but they can all afford a poor result at this point.  Mark faces Mick in the game of the week and, although it is much more meaningful for Mick, Mark does have the opportunity to knock one of the top 6 teams (on paper) almost out of the playoff hunt with a win here.

Smackdown It looks pretty clear that Mick, Robby, and Scott are all fighting for the last playoff spot.  Robby took a big hit with Diggs getting hurt, but at least he's got an easy matchup this week to cushion the blow.  Scott and Mick both have tougher tests this week, and Mick especially needs a win as he heads into another game as an underdog next week.

Week 8 Primer

Raw The top teams in the Raw Division are all expected to win, and Blake is the only one of them who should have a tough matchup.  Ultimately, the results this week shouldn't ding anyone's playoff hopes too much.  After another unexpected win, Matt might only be one or two upsets away from being a playoff threat.

Smackdown Emil continues to be solidly in-line for a playoff spot, even through he's a slight underdog this week.  Beyond him, the Division is pretty wide open.  Vlad is expected to win, but wasn't helped by a fluky Thursday night performance that helped Mike take an early lead.  Mick and Scott are big favorites, and really can't afford to lose.  But its Robby vs Ian that is highlighted as the Game of the Week.  A loss wouldn't be killer (in fact its expected), but a win would put Robby squarely in the driver's seat for the final playoff spot heading into a managable stretch of games.

Week 7 Primer

Raw Blake finds himself in the biggest game of the week as another loss would put him in a scary spot with 3 legit opponents (Emil, Vlad, Mark) ahead over the next 3 weeks.  Ian has played himself into some safety, even though he's the underdog this week.  Mark is also an underdog, but given his record and point total he's safe as well.

Smackdown Mick is under some pressure and a loss vs Blake this week will probably drop his playoff odds below 50%.  Robby and Scott have easy matchups that should see them each improve to 4-3.  Emil and Vlad have risen above the pack and its hard to see them not make the playoffs at this point.

Playoff odds by week

Highlighting how much playoff odds have changed over time.  The bad teams have been confirmed bad while Scott has slipped compared to preseason expectations.

Week 6 Primer

Raw Surprisingly, in the first week of cross-division play the biggest favorite from the Raw side is Mike, who is expected to give Scott a major dent to his playoff hopes.  Mark, Matt, and Eric are big underdogs, but there doesn't project to be a major change in playoff expectations.  Blake vs Robby is the game of the week, but the importance is really on Robby's side since Blake should be in good shape regardless.

Also, big shoutout to Matt: a playoff team after 1/3 of the season!  No one had that on their bingo cards (including the model, which only expects another 1 or 2 wins for him the rest of the way).

Smackdown Emil and Vlad have stepped up as the teams to beat in Smackdown, but Mick will have a great shot to get back to winning this week.  Bye weeks give Scott a very tough task against Mike, and Robby can jump back up to the 4th spot in the division with a big win over Blake.  The model really doesn't like where Robby would be with a loss, making this almost like an early must-win.

Week 5 Primer

Raw After a big win in week 4, Ian is now the clear favorite to take the last playoff spot.  He can't let a matchup vs the last winless team in the league derail his hopes though. The two division leaders are also expected to win, though the matchup for Mark is projected as the 2nd closest one this week.

Smackdown The most fun matchup this week actually isn't the game of the week.  Emil and Mick face off in what is the closest thing to a true rivalry between hated rivals.  Whether they admit it or not, come Monday night one of them will be very happy to put a small dent in the other's playoff hopes (or a medium dent if Mick is the one losing).  

The actual game of the week is the most important matchup of the season so far.  Robby and Scott are directly competing with Ian for the last playoff spot and a single win could make the difference.  Considering Scott's cross-division schedule looks soft, there is probably more pressure on Robby to win here..

Week 4 Primer

Raw None of the matchups in the Raw division are very interesting this week.  The one matchup that should make a big impact on the playoff run (Mark vs Ian) is also projected to be the biggest blowout of the week.  An upset victory would be big though!

Smackdown Emil vs Scott is the game of the week, but every matchup in this division had a case for the recognition.  Neither Emil or Scott will be down too bad with a loss, but a win for Emil will put him squarely in the top 3/4 in playoff odds.  For Scott, the result will either put him a step above or below the middle of the pack.  Robby is in the same boat as Scott with the matchup this week, and Vlad could make a big jump in playoff odds with a win.

Week 3 Primer

Raw Ian's win last week puts him on the playoff track, but he's got to take care of business again this week in order to remain on course.  The other matchups won't matter for the playoff picture and probably won't be competitive.  The fact that the 3 worst teams in the league are in this division makes things boring until we get into inter-division play next week.

Smackdown Every matchup this week is pretty interesting in the Smackdown division.  Scott's matchup headlines, since a poor showing for Rhamondre on Thursday makes him the underdog in a matchup that he's really got to win.  Emil vs Vlad appears to be the tightest matchup of the week and is pretty much a must-win for Vlad.  Robby projects to be compettive vs Mick and a win would be big for him.

Week 2 Primer

Raw Mark and Blake face-off for the early division lead, but ultimately both teams should be on track to make the playoffs.  A more interesting matchup is Ian's vs Mike.  Despite losing Jordan Love for a while, Ian hopes to be on the playoff bubble, but starting 0-2 will be tough since it will mean he'll only have 4 more losses to take all year in order to reach a safe-ish 8 wins.

Smackdown Like Ian, Robby and Vlad will be in a tough spot if they drop to 0-2, making their matchup the top one this week.  However, Scott's matchup vs Mick is projected to be the tightest and is also compelling as Scott could play himself up from the playoff bubble into the pole position in the division.  Emil also has to be on guard, this matchup isn't projected to be a blowout, but its a win he needs in order to have some breathing room vs the top teams.

Week 1 Primer

Raw The tightest matchup in the Raw division figures to be between non-playoff-contenders Eric & Mike.  Blake vs Ian is the actual headline matchup for this division in week 1, an upset victory could be important to a fringe playoff contender like Ian.

Smackdown In a competitive division, the week 1 matchup between Vlad and Scott could have significant implications as the season goes on.  The models don't love Robby's team, but the matchup vs Emil figures to be competitive and Robby needs to pull off an upset or 3 to be in the playoff conversation.  This week, even the weakest team in the division (Rich) still has a puncher's chance vs the projected favorite (Mick).

2024 tiers: The Favorites

#2 Blake (was #4 in April):  Projected bench RB Aaron Jones was this team's only major free agent acquisition, so the climb from #4 in April to #2 now was fueled by some savvy trades.  More than half of the projected starters came in via May-June trades (Josh Allen, Mixon, Jefferson, Olave, and Adams).  Despite making those huge acquisitions, Blake maintained a huge surplus of future picks & built up strong bench depth (aside from QB).  This team is set up to challenge for a 2nd title in 3 years.

Team Resiliency (depth & pick inventory to withstand injuries): A

#1 Mark (was #1 in April): Mark's team looked the strongest in April and has only gotten better since then.  However, out of all of the FA and trade acquisitions, only the Cooper Kupp great value pickup brings in a clear starter.  Everyone else who was added (Conner, Rodgers, Keenan Allen, Christian Kirk) helped build some of the best competitive depth in the league.  This team's only weakness is a lack of future picks to make opportunistic trades in-season, otherwise this squad is top notch.

Team Resiliency (depth & pick inventory to withstand injuries): A-

2024 tiers: LEGIT contenders

#4 Vlad (was #11 in April):  Vlad's offseason renovations hit all the right areas to shape the team into a 2024 contender.  Daniels is a day 1 starter and high upside QB, Henry could have a monster year, and most people would still bet on Kelce being a strong contributor.  Overall, this team ranks top 5 in the league at all starting position groups, excluding Flex.  The lack of dependable quality depth starts to show at Flex and this team really needs a Ridley/Singletary/Mostert type guy to hit big.

Team Resiliency (depth & pick inventory to withstand injuries): C+

#3 Mick (was #7 in April): Mick's rebuild looks like its near completion and this team has a real chance to win this seasonBy adding CMC, the RB group became the best in the league and Saquon projects to be the best Flex out there.  However, among the 6 contenders, this squad has the 5th rated QB and TE situation and the worst WR group.  Still, with multiple first round picks still in the holster and many high upside players on the bench, it does seem like a sustained run is in the cards in 2024.

Team Resiliency (depth & pick inventory to withstand injuries): B+

2024 tiers: longshot contenders

Editor's Note: Since Emil and Ian decided to be assholes and make a trade in the middle of my previews, it has changed the projections slightly.  It hasn't actually changed the power rankings or tier placement though, so I'm not going back to rewrite anything.  Ian's projected points reflect his improved lineup with James Cook.

#6 Scott (was #6 in April):  Adding Mike Evans in Free Agency solidified the WR position as the best WR trio in the league.  Mahomes and Stafford are good enough to project as the 3rd best QB group among contenders and TE seems appears to be good enough with Njoku.  The RB position is the clear question mark, with Rhamondre being a low-level RB1 at best and Ekeler a very risky RB2.  If things go well early in the season, this team could cash in some future picks to solidify depth.

Team Resiliency (depth & pick inventory to withstand injuries): C+

#5 Emil (was #9 in April): No one has been more active than Emil this offseason and in the end this team appears headed towards a playoff berth (at least)The team projects to have the 4th best RB, 5th best WR, and 4th best starter at Flex in the league.  Yet TE is a question mark until Hockenson comes back and the starting QBs surprisingly project to have the lowest combined PPG out of all contenders.   Having already traded most valuable picks does handcuff this team a bit as well.

Team Resiliency (depth & pick inventory to withstand injuries): B

2024 tiers: a few pieces away

#10 Eric (was #8 in April):  Trading away Josh Allen was a sacrifice that could pay off in the long run.  Adding Nabers to the WRs brought that group up to the top 6 in the league and TE is a strength thanks to getting Kittle on one of the best value FA deals.  On the other hand, this looked like a bad QB situation even with JJ McCarthy in the mix, with him out of the picture it is probably the worst in the league.  While Eric has draft capital to move, it may be better to look to the future.

#9 Robby (was #10 in April): Robby has made some nice additions since April, notably Kamara, Metcalf, and Pollard.  The new RBs give the team good depth, as Pollard projects to be a top 5 flex play in the league.  However, Robby's team is full of big names (Herbert, Lawrence, Najee, Diggs) who people are notably low on.  The QB and WR situations rank 7th and 10th, but the opportunity to overperform is there and Robby still has '26 and '27 1sts that he can cash in to support a run.

#8 Rich (was #5 in April): Rich has clearly been looking to the future, trading away Davante Adams, Higgins, Montgomery, and Etienne (all to Emil) since April.  Russell Wilson, Swift, and Jeudy are all new acquisitions that figure to start for this team, but that is a reflection of the average state of their RB and WR groups.  Not to mention the downright bad QB situation, which projects as 11th in the league.  However, with four 1sts over the next 2 classes, Rich can definitely be aggressive if things go well.

#7 Ian (was #3 in April): It has been a disappointing offseason for IanWithout any high 2024 draft picks or enough cap space to make any FA acquisitions, it was always going to be tough sledding.  However, trades have also taken this team in a weird direction, mostly because the current RB2 options (likely Trey Benson) can't compare to Jonathan Taylor's upside.  Without an injury to James Conner, this team figures to have a huge weakness at RB2 and with only one future 1st it could be tough to fill it.

2024 tiers: The bottom feeders

#12 Matt (was #12 in April):  Despite being the 2nd most improved team since the spring, on paper this is still the worst squad for the 2024 season.  The strength of this team is at QB, where the additions of Kyler Murray and Drake Maye take them up to #7 at the position.  However, the remaining position groups are all bottom 3 in the league.  There are some interesting players for the future, but no one who projects to be far above replacement-level in 2024.

#11 Mike (was #2 in April): In terms of their short-term outlook, this team has nose-dived from their top 2 position in April.  Now that CMC has been traded away, any hope of being a dark horse playoff contender and repeating as Champions has certainly evaporated.  Like Matt's team, this group is led by the QB position, which ranks 3rd in the league.  Every other position group ranks 11th, so this is really the Lamar Jackson and Caleb Williams show in 2024.  

Who had the best offseason?

Now that we're a month away from the start of the regular season, we can take a closer look at how the teams stack up.  First up we'll look at which teams have given themselves an improved chance to win in 2024 through their moves this spring and summer.